Yesterday I met a mother who was about to lose her daughter. The daughter was only twenty-eight years old, with advanced breast cancer that had spread to her liver, bones, and lymph nodes. For the previous week she had been cycling through emergency visits for pain, delirium, agitation, restlessnes…
the familiar signs that life was approaching its final chapter. Eventually the family brought her to hospice.
When I arrived for duty, the young woman was resting. The nurses told me her story.
She had lost her father in early childhood and was raised solely by her mother. During her illness journey, she had spent time living in a gurdwara, where she engaged in service activities such as cooking and serving. The mother, deeply distressed by her daughter’s illness, had pursued multiple avenues of hope, including faith-based practices and alternative treatments such as leech therapy.
Looking back, others called it ignorance. Some relatives blamed her. Her daughter herself had blamed her repeatedly.
By the time I met the mother, she seemed to exist in a psychological storm. She would cry one moment and laugh the next. She appeared restless, fragmented, unable to settle.. I have seen grief before, but this felt different. It felt as though she was carrying not only impending loss but also a crushing burden of guilt.
Guilt…It is not simply an emotion. It is often an attempt to rewrite the past.
The guilty mind refuses to accept reality’s final verdict. It searches endlessly for the point where history could have been altered.
“If only I had done this.”
“If only I had chosen differently.”
“If only I had known.”
The problem is that the past does not negotiate but the mind continues the argument anyway.
But standing in front of that woman, I was also reminded that human beings do not make decisions from a place of perfect information. They make decisions from fear, hope, love, desperation, culture, faith, and the unbearable need to protect those they love.
Anthropologists often describe rituals, pilgrimages, prayers, and traditional healing practices as systems of meaning. Psychologists describe them as attempts to restore a sense of control in situations of profound uncertainty.
At the bedside, however, these explanations feel incomplete.
What I saw was a mother who had spent years searching for a way to save her daughter.
Perhaps some of those searches were misguided.
But they were still searches born of love.
Later that evening, she came to me in tears. She wanted to take her daughter home or perhaps to another hospital. Usually, in such situations, I discuss prognosis, risks, benefits, and realistic expectations. I explain why another transfer may not change the outcome.
For some reason, I could not do that with her.
I sensed that the request was not entirely about medical care. It .was about guilt.
Perhaps she was trying to save her daughter.
Perhaps she was trying to save herself from the unbearable accusation that she had not done enough.
At times I feel we human beings struggle more with helplessness than with suffering itself. Action gives us the illusion of control. Even futile action can feel psychologically safer than acceptance.
Acceptance is difficult because it asks us to acknowledge limits.
Not the patient’s limits.
Our own.
The mother’s tragedy may not be that she made imperfect choices.
Every parent does.
Her tragedy may be that she now carries the impossible burden of believing that she alone authored an outcome shaped by biology, chance, circumstance, medicine, culture, and time.
No single human being possesses that much power.
As I watched her, I found myself wondering whether her greatest suffering was not the impending death of her daughter, but the belief that she had failed her.
Yet from another perspective, she had spent twenty-eight years refusing to abandon her child.
She searched.
She prayed.
She hoped.
She fought.
She made mistakes.
She loved.
Perhaps all mothers do some version of the same.
In hospice we often witness the death of the body.
But sometimes we also witness another struggle the desperate attempt of the living to forgive themselves before the person they love disappears.
And that struggle can be every bit as painful as the disease itself.
Leave a Reply